Medical equipment and copier lease returns: removing PHI first
Lease returns and trade-ins are where protected health information most often leaves a healthcare organization by accident. The device goes back on schedule, nobody checks its internal drive, and the data goes with it. The best-known case cost a health plan more than $1.2 million.
The case that made this a known risk
Affinity Health Plan returned multiple leased photocopiers without erasing their hard drives. A news organization bought one of the copiers and found medical information on its drive. HHS found the PHI of up to 344,579 people had been disclosed, that Affinity hadn't included the copiers' drives in its risk analysis, and that it had no procedures for returning drives to leasing agents. Affinity settled for $1,215,780 in 2013.
A lease return process that works
- Flag data-bearing devices at signing. Note in the lease which devices store data and who will sanitize them at return.
- Track end dates in the same system as your other asset retirements.
- Before return, sanitize or remove the storage. Either the lessor sanitizes and certifies in writing, or your ITAD provider removes and destroys the drive before pickup. Some lessors offer drive retention for a fee.
- Get a certificate listing the device serial, the storage serial, the method and the date.
- File it with your HIPAA security documentation.
Devices to watch
| Device | What it can hold |
|---|---|
| Workstations, laptops and tablets | EHR access, downloaded reports, cached files and email |
| Servers, storage arrays and backup tapes | EHR databases, PACS image archives, backups |
| Imaging systems (CT, MRI, X-ray, ultrasound consoles) | Patient images and identifiers stored on the console's internal drives |
| Lab analyzers and patient monitors | Test results, patient identifiers and logs on internal storage |
| Infusion pumps and other networked bedside devices | Drug libraries, patient data and network credentials, depending on model |
| Multifunction copiers, printers and fax machines | An image of every page scanned, copied or faxed on an internal drive |
| Phones, pagers and voice systems | Messages, contacts and call logs |
Common questions
Can we keep the copier's hard drive when we return it?
Often, yes. Many lessors offer drive removal or retention, sometimes for a fee. Ask before the return date and get the arrangement in writing.
Does the leasing company have to sign a BAA?
That depends on whether it handles PHI on your behalf. If the device will leave with data on it, the safer course is to make sure it doesn't: sanitize or remove the drive first. Ask your privacy officer.
Sources
- HHS: Affinity Health Plan photocopier breach settlement
- 45 CFR 164.310, physical safeguards (device and media controls)
- HHS: Guidance to render unsecured PHI unusable, unreadable or indecipherable
Reviewed November 2026. Laws change; confirm current requirements with the agency or your counsel.